Media Release – CJ Palmer Appeal Verdict

The WA Court of Appeal has today handed down a unanimous verdict to allow the appeal made by CJ Palmer and to reduce her sentence from 6 years to 4, against the charge of grievous bodily harm for the transmission of HIV to her ex-partner. CJ Palmer will now be eligible for parole as of April 1st, 2019.

The WA Court of Appeal have accepted the appeal made by CJ Palmer against her sentence, in a unanimous ruling on the basis that the sentence delivered on 16/02/18 was manifestly excessive.

Lena Van Hale, Manager of the WA sex worker support project Magenta states, “We applaud the decision from the WA Court of Appeal to reduce CJ Palmer’s sentence to 4 years. There is more evidence than ever before that punitive laws criminalising HIV transmission are harmful to public health. While our laws do not yet recognise international best practise in this space. In recognising the original sentence as manifestly excessive the WA court of appeal take the first step toward undoing that harm.”

Evidence shows that criminalisation in these cases is detrimental to public health. Criminalisation of non-intentional HIV transmission reduces rates of testing, does not reduce HIV transmissions, and undermines effective health promotion.

“We are happy for CJ and her family to hear this decision from the Court of Appeal today. We hope that CJ’s remaining time in the criminal justice system is free from the harmful coverage and discrimination that surrounded her incarceration”

Throughout her trial advocates called for courts and policy-makers to reject the application of criminal law in cases of alleged non-intentional HIV transmission, in line with Australia’s existing Guidelines for the Management of People with HIV who Place Others at Risk, and in line with UNAIDS guidance around management of HIV transmission.

What is Harm Reduction?

What is Harm Reduction?

Harm reduction is a fancy term, commonly used in reference to substance use. That said, harm reduction is a strategy used by health and community services, such as Magenta, to deliver their services. Harm reduction is not about encouraging behaviours with associated risk, but about accepting that we all take risks as people and it is important that we minimise any potential harm.

Think about a car; we jump in and put on our seatbelt. Being in a car involves an element of risk, but wearing a seatbelt is a form of harm reduction. Seatbelts are proven to reduce risk of harm if a car crashes. Covering your mouth when you cough reduces the risk of passing along your cold to others; again, it is about the reduction of harm to others and ourselves. As individuals, we practice harm reduction every day.

Why does Magenta use harm reduction?

Magenta uses harm reduction principles because they are effective, evidence based, empowering and most importantly, client focused.

Harm reduction is not about ‘saving’ or ‘rescuing’ any person. It is a client-led model based on individual’s needs. It is Magenta’s role to support a person without judgement or assumption. The result is an empowered person who makes realistic choices in their lives to minimise the risk of harm.

The harm reduction approach provides all sex workers with a non-judgmental and supportive service, resulting in increased health outcomes and increased empowerment of the individuals.

What does harm reduction look like for sex workers?

Harm reduction is different for everyone and unique to your needs, goals and circumstances. Common advice given to sex workers is make sure to save your money so you can afford to be sick.

Let us break this down. You have three workers, all catch a cold, but the harm reduction approach to each situation is unique.

Lucy works in a nearby parlour 1-3 nights per week around her study, upon starting in the industry she has no savings and is in a small amount of debt. 3 months later, Lucy catches a cold, she still has no savings, and her expenses remain the same. Lucy decides to work a shift, taking the next day off school to rest, and recover.

Ben works full time hours as a sex worker privately. When he starts he owns his home, has minimal expenses and $3000 in savings. When Ben contracts a cold he chooses to take two weeks off work to reduce the risk of giving it to clients and allow himself time to rest and recover.

Jasmine lives in Albany and is a single mother who tours Perth occasionally when she does not have care of her children. Jasmine is touring Perth for two weeks. One week into the tour, she gets a cold. She has covered her touring costs and home expenses, but has not made profit. Jasmine decides to continue to work, minimising the risk by informing clients of her cold and avoiding kissing, working to make money and return home with enough profit to recover from the flu and cover new school supplies for her children.

Harm reductions works to empower and support the individual person.

Other examples of harm reduction for sex workers;

  • Using condoms, dams, gloves and other safer sex supplies to reduce the health and legal risks to sex workers.
  • Being educated around STI and BBV transmission
  • Being knowledgeable about the legislation in the area that you work
  • Sharing information on ‘ugly mugs’ with other workers
  • Keeping sex worker safety tips within the sex worker community only
  • Screening clients in a way you feel works for YOU
  • Negotiating consent clearly

Working my way

Being bipolar and a sex worker has been an interesting journey. If you missed my post about that, you can have a read here. However, this is about how harm reduction and peer education supported my work and life. It is about working my way with support and advice from other sex workers.

Part of bipolar for me is mania, specifically hyper-sexuality. Which means I am super interested in working and do not always make the best choices. When I was figuring out how to work and manage my mental health I was seeking support from Magenta peer educators. These people may not have had bipolar, but they had been sex workers.

At first, I thought ‘how can these people, who do not live my life,  understand’? How can these condom selling health experts give me any advice other than ‘just don’t work’, which I’ve already been told by my psychiatrist. My sex worker friends pushed me into reaching out. Telling me that it was worth it and suggesting there was no harm in asking. So, I did.

I was honest with the educator about my mental health. I was possibly more honest than I should have been, but I was using a fake name  so I was totally anonymous. It kind of felt like going to a confessional. I told this educator about not charging for extra’s, running over time, doing services that I do not offer and taking health risks. I told her about the pressure I faced from clients who returned to see me when I was stable who then expected the same service and the aggression that could result if I said no.

This Magenta staff member did not judge me; in fact she listened and contributed similar experiences and a non-judgemental space. She even had advice on methods I could use to set boundaries. Things like; not working when manic, becoming a ‘touring’ worker with a different name and service description for manic periods, only seeing regulars and having a ‘menu’ of services that I don’t detour from. When I said something would not work for me, she listened to why and helped me to develop ways of working that would.

What I did not realise then is that harm reduction and peer education is not this super formal, complex approach. It is simply sharing information from the community and using the advice that best fits your way of working.

Magenta Stock List

Magenta has recently updated the stock list available for purchase in our shop.




Ansell Condoms – 144 in Gross  $   25.00  $       –  $   25.00
Ansell Condoms – 12 singles  $     2.40  $       –  $     2.40
Four Seasons Condoms -144 in Gross  $   30.00  $       –  $   30.00
Four Seasons Condoms -12 Singles  $     3.00  $       –  $     3.00
Glyde Condoms – 100 in Gross  $   20.00  $       –  $   20.00
Glyde Condoms – 10 Singles  $     2.00  $       –  $     2.00
Femidom (female condom) – Single  $     3.50  $       –  $     3.50
Finger Cots – 100 in Gross  $   10.00  $    1.00  $   11.00
Finger Cots – Pack of 10  $     1.00  $    0.10  $     1.10
Dental Dams – 100 in Box  $   55.00  $       –  $   55.00
Dental Dams – Single  $     0.55  $       –  $     0.55
Gloves – 100 in box  $   10.91  $   1.09  $   12.00
Gloves – 10 Singles  $     1.82  $   0.18  $     2.00


Wet Stuff  Gold – 60 g  $     4.00  $       –  $     4.00
Wet Stuff   Gold – 270g  $   11.00  $       –  $   11.00
Wet Stuff  Gold – 100g  $     5.00  $       –  $     5.00
Wet Stuff Gold 550g  $   16.00  $   16.00
Wet Stuff – 550g (pump or flip)  $   15.00  $       –  $   15.00
Wet Stuff – 270g (pump or flip)  $   11.00  $       –  $   11.00
Wet Stuff – 100g tube  $     5.00  $       –  $     5.00
Wet Stuff Sachets (packs of 10)  $     2.00  $       –  $     2.00
Wet Stuff Secrets Lube -250g  $     8.50  $   0.85  $     9.35
Wet Stuff Secrets Lube – 100g  $     5.50  $   0.55  $     6.05
Glyde 100ml Lube  $     4.00  –  $     4.00
Glyde 500ml Lube  $     8.00  –  $     8.00
Glyde 1ltr Lube  $   12.00  –  $   12.00


Beppy Sponge – Bag of 8  $   24.00  $   2.40  $   26.40
Beppy Sponge – Each  $     3.00  $   0.30  $     3.30
Beppy Wet Bag – Bag of 8  $   28.00  $   2.80  $   30.80
Beppy Wet Sponge – Each  $     3.50  $   0.35  $     3.85

Toys (each)

Pornhub Wand Set  $   110.00  $   11.00  $   121.00
We-Vibe $    68.00  $   6.80  $   74.80
Prostatic Prostate Vibe  $   30.00  $   3.00  $   33.00
Plunged Hollow Plug  $   45.00  $   4.50  $   49.50
Vibrating Prostate stimulator  $   21.00  $   2.10  $   23.10
Feranti Rose Collection  $   40.00  $   4.00  $   44.00
Love Beads  $     8.00  $   0.80  $     8.80
Butt Plug  $     8.00  $   0.80  $     8.80
Neon Luv Touch Bullet  $   12.00  $   1.20  $   13.20
Lamour Premium Vibe  $   25.74  $   2.86  $   28.60
Pornhub Bondage set  $   70.00  $   7.00  $   77.00
Airflow Cockring  $   20.00  $   2.00  $   22.00
Zoe Chrome Vibrator Massager  $   27.00  $   2.70  $   29.70
Her Royal Harness Me2 Rumble  $   67.00  $   6.70  $   73.70
Her Royal Harness The Countess  $   48.00  $   4.80  $   52.80
Bombshell Balm Gift Set  $   26.00  $   2.60  $   28.60
Multi Wanachi Vibe  $  40.00  $  4.00  $  44.00
Coco Rose Gold  $   22.00  $   2.20  $   24.20
Sinful Nylon Rope  $   12.00  $   1.20  $   13.20

One sex workers open letter to her future mental health professional

A letter to the professional I am about to see for my mental health.

You may be a doctor, a counsellor, a social worker, a support worker, a psychologist or a psychiatrist. I am coming to an appointment and I am very nervous. You see, I am a sex worker. In the past I have seen professionals for my mental health in emergency rooms, therapist offices and doctor offices only to be leave feeling less than. I am writing you this letter as a sex worker, to discuss some of the things you should know.

  1. I have internalised stigma. This means that when you make certain comments, use problematic language, reinforce untrue stereotypes or pass judgement through body language you can reinforce this internal struggle. I know sex work is real work, I know I enjoy it. However, I face the struggle of societies whorephobia and when I am vulnerable someone I am trusting with my mental health can confirm these. I will walk away feeling like my choice of occupation, my life, myself is not worthy of help, is not allowed to be helped. Alternatively, I may walk away assuming you are part of the problem, angry and defiant. This will guarantee that anything helpful I could have taken from this appointment will be disregarded.
  2. Do not make assumptions on my past, present or future. Do not assume that story follows that of stereotypes, pop culture or the other sex worker you met. Let me tell you my story and listen. Do not ask me, in thirty different ways, about the trauma, pressure or drug use that ‘pushed’ me into ‘that line of work’. Trust my answers to your questions the first time.
  3. Try to avoid looking me up and down. It shows you are judging me. This action causes me to assume you are thinking things like ‘people actually pay to touch that thing in front of me’ or I assume you are being incredibly leery and inappropriate. Neither of which make me feel safe with you.
  4. Leaving the sex industry will not magically cure me. I like my job, it allows me to pay to see you and provides me with freedom. Even if I didn’t like my job, pressure to leave can be insurmountable with financial pressures, gaps in my resume and self-doubt. If I want to discuss leaving the industry I will bring it up. I will ask for advice on certain things. Do not be the professional who bases my mental health around my leaving my job.
  5. Your language matters. I may call myself a lot of things. I have been told off by countless professionals for calling myself crazy in your offices. This shows you understand the power of problematic language. Do not use stigmatising language. The accepted term is sex worker. However, if you not sure ask how I would like you to refer to my job.
  6. I have a life, relationships, friendships and commitments outside sex work. If I do not want to discuss sex work in every appointment that is okay. Sex work is not the cause of my mental illness and ignoring the large portion of my life that occurs outside of my work is not going help.
  7. Do not make stigmatising comments or jokes in our sessions. This includes problematic language, pop culture references and anything that reinforces the stigma. This will break my trust and likely result in me leaving your service.

These are seven things I wanted you to know. The final, and to me most important, thing is this; I do not trust you. I am in a position of requiring help with my mental health. I want to get well and understand that honesty will assist this, so I am telling you about sex work. But you need to understand that I don’t trust you. I am going to be difficult, I am going to judge your reactions and comments harshly. Please don’t isolate me by putting any of your moral objections to my occupation onto me.

Understand I will be difficult. I may ask to see your note. I may tell you to not write my occupation down. I might be stubborn. I may cry. If you can’t do these things, if your personal ethics do not allow you to see me as equal then please tell me straight up. I want someone willing to work with me. I want a professional who is willing to listen. I don’t trust you, but I want to.


The nervous sex worker who is scared you are another professional that is going to betray my trust.